Difference between revisions of "User:Ickputzdirwech/Weapons"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(13 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Summary == | == Summary == | ||
− | This page is | + | This page is supposed to provide some data for comparison between different melee weapons. |
− | == | + | == Comparison tables == |
− | The following | + | The following tables compares the {{DPS}} of weapons of the same material and quality. |
− | {| {{STDT| | + | * Since you realistically only ever want to make sharp weapons out of [[plasteel]], [[steel]] or [[uranium]], only those materials are considered. |
− | ! | + | * [[Melee hit chance]] can be ignored, since we look only at relative differences. |
− | ! | + | |
− | ! | + | === {{Icon Small|Longsword}} Longsword vs. {{Icon Small|Spear}} Spear === |
− | ! | + | Green indicates, that the [[longsword]] is better, red the [[spear]]. |
− | ! | + | |
+ | ==== Baseline human ==== | ||
+ | {{#vardefineecho:weapon1|Longsword}} vs. {{#vardefineecho:weapon2|Spear}} | ||
+ | {| {{STDT|c_06 text-right}} | ||
+ | ! Quality !! {{Icon Small|Plasteel}} !! {{Icon Small|Steel}} !! {{Icon Small|Uranium}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | ! {{ | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Awful}} |
− | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} | |
− | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} | |
− | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} | |
− | |||
− | |||
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | ||
− | | {{#var: | ||
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Poor}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Normal}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Good}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Excellent}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Masterwork}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Legendary}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{# | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | |- | + | |} |
− | + | ||
− | + | ==== Archotech arms ==== | |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | {{#vardefineecho:weapon1|Longsword}} vs. {{#vardefineecho:weapon2|Spear}} |
− | | {{#var: | + | {| {{STDT| c_06 text-right}} |
− | | {{ | + | ! Quality !! {{Icon Small|Plasteel}} !! {{Icon Small|Steel}} !! {{Icon Small|Uranium}} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Awful}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Poor}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Normal}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Good}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Excellent}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Masterwork}} |
− | | {{# | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} | |
− | | | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | ||
− | | {{#var: | ||
− | | {{# | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Legendary}} |
− | | {{# | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr: {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human|Archotech arm|Archotech arm}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | | + | |} |
− | + | ||
− | | {{# | + | ==== Conclusions ==== |
− | | | + | * Whether the longsword or spear has more {{DPS}} is dependant on: |
− | + | ** '''Mostly''' the chosen '''material'''. | |
− | | | + | ** '''Somewhat''' the achieved '''quality'''. |
− | + | ** '''Somewhat''' on the attacks available to the pawn. Default attacks: left fist, right fist, teeth, head. Changed by injuries and artificial body parts (e.g. [[Bionic arm|bionic]] or [[archotech arm]]s, [[elbow blade]]s {{RoyaltyIcon}}, [[knee spike]]s {{RoyaltyIcon}} or [[venom fangs]] {{RoyaltyIcon}}). | |
− | | {{ | + | * '''However''', for materials you actually want to choose ([[plasteel]], [[steel]] or [[uranium]]), the differences rarely reach 2%. |
− | | {{# | + | |
− | | {{#expr: | + | Conclusion: As for pure {{DPS}} there is no clear winner between longsword and spear. |
− | | | + | |
− | + | === {{Icon Small|Spear}} Spear vs. {{Icon Small|Mace}} Mace === | |
− | | {{ | + | Green indicates, that the [[longsword]] is better, red the [[spear]]. |
− | | {{ | + | |
− | | {{ | + | ==== Baseline human ==== |
− | + | {{#vardefineecho:weapon1|Spear}} vs. {{#vardefineecho:weapon2|Mace}} | |
− | + | {| {{STDT|c_06 text-right}} | |
− | + | ! Quality !! {{Icon Small|Plasteel}} !! {{Icon Small|Steel}} !! {{Icon Small|Uranium}} | |
− | |||
− | | | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Awful}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{# | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | |- | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | | {{#expr: | ||
− | |||
− | |||
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Poor}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Normal}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Good}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Excellent}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Masterwork}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|- | |- | ||
− | ! | + | ! {{#vardefineecho:quality|Legendary}} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Plasteel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#var: | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Steel|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
− | | {{#expr: {{Melee | + | | {{#ifexpr: {{#vardefineecho:difference|{{#expr:{{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon1}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} / {{True Melee DPS Calculator|{{#var:weapon2}}|Uranium|{{#var:quality}}|Human}} -1}} }} >= 0 | {{Good|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} | {{Bad|{{%|{{#var:difference}}|4}} }} }} |
|} | |} |
Latest revision as of 14:08, 27 April 2023
Summary[edit]
This page is supposed to provide some data for comparison between different melee weapons.
Comparison tables[edit]
The following tables compares the DPS of weapons of the same material and quality.
- Since you realistically only ever want to make sharp weapons out of plasteel, steel or uranium, only those materials are considered.
- Melee hit chance can be ignored, since we look only at relative differences.
Longsword vs. Spear[edit]
Green indicates, that the longsword is better, red the spear.
Baseline human[edit]
Longsword vs. Spear
Archotech arms[edit]
Longsword vs. Spear
Conclusions[edit]
- Whether the longsword or spear has more DPS is dependant on:
- Mostly the chosen material.
- Somewhat the achieved quality.
- Somewhat on the attacks available to the pawn. Default attacks: left fist, right fist, teeth, head. Changed by injuries and artificial body parts (e.g. bionic or archotech arms, elbow blades , knee spikes or venom fangs ).
- However, for materials you actually want to choose (plasteel, steel or uranium), the differences rarely reach 2%.
Conclusion: As for pure DPS there is no clear winner between longsword and spear.
Spear vs. Mace[edit]
Green indicates, that the longsword is better, red the spear.
Baseline human[edit]
Spear vs. Mace